Read Sixth in August/September 2011.
I. Love. Harry Potter. These are definitely some of the books I read before the challenge. I leaped for joy when I saw that they were on the list. And NO, I don't like Harry Potter for the movies, it's for the books. I writhe with anger and fury when I experience a conversation that goes like this:
I. Love. Harry Potter. These are definitely some of the books I read before the challenge. I leaped for joy when I saw that they were on the list. And NO, I don't like Harry Potter for the movies, it's for the books. I writhe with anger and fury when I experience a conversation that goes like this:
Me: "Do you like Harry Potter?"
Them: "Eh. I never really got into it."
Them: "Eh. I never really got into it."
Me: "What? How?"
Them: "Oh, I thought it was poorly done. I think the actors were just too young."
Me: "...You're talking about the movies."
Them: "Yeah...?"
Me: "What about the books?"
Them: "Oh, I never read them. They're too long. Have you seen Twilight?"
On a similar note, I HATE it when people compare Harry Potter and Twilight. And yes, I've read Twilight. I don't criticize things of which I know nothing. Therefore, I have the right to criticize Twilight.
Anyways...
I often find that series like this got lucky at first and decline in quality. But Harry Potter was so well-written and masterly done that it definitely stands out amongst any book. Sometimes I find that a book is very good at the beginning, but the author didn't know when he/she wrote it how the book would end. This is not that case. Rowling had the end in mind very much before she started writing it. Rowling also does very well with character development. At times (the Order of the Phoenix especially), I hate Harry and the things he does. He is so angsty and it's obnoxious. But isn't that human? If I think if I were in his situation, would I have done anything better? I don't think I would. The fact that every character has flaws makes them all the better. Not even Dumbledore is perfect, as we come to find out in the Deathly Hallows, nor James, Sirius, or Lupin.
I could talk for hours about Harry Potter. It's pretty much the greatest thing ever. And I very deeply regret not having a Pottermore account YET...
Hypothetical hugs for Harry Potter forever! I, too, hate it when people try to compare HP to Twilight, even favorably. Harry Potter doesn't need to be good for Twilight to be terrible. There is enough evidence to support the "Twilight is terrible" theory IN Twilight, so I don't see why we need a thousand "What you like Twilight haven't you ever read Harry Potter it's the best EVAAAAAR <3<3<3" groups on Facebook.
ReplyDelete